Courtesy Readers Digest 1981. November.
From the frontiers of science and the far horizons of
personal courage, these stories of medical triumphs and miracles will reaffirm
your faith in the awesome powers of the human spirit. Dramatic victories and human
triumphs
The following account of a young man’s critical operation is
based largely on several months that Lawrence Sheinberg spend with the chief of
neurosurgery and his associates in a major eastern teaching hospital. The names of all persons have been changed
and the locations disguises.
Perhaps Charlie White’s tumor was present at his birth, but
his trip to neurosurgery did not begin until two weeks after his 31st birthday,
when he stood up from his desk to go to lunch and dropped to the floor with an
epileptic seizure. No illness or warning
preceded that attack. For 50 seconds he
felt as though his heart had stopped, and for three minutes his left leg shook
gently, as if keeping time to music.
Six days after the seizure, on a cold March afternoon,
Charlie White come to Osler Memorial Hospital to meet with neurosurgeon James
Brockman, the man they called the Boss around the ward. For all the weakness in his knees, Charlie
was inexplicably excited. Since his
seizure, life had been intense. He saw
everything, took nothing for granted. In
some ways he had never felt better.
Charlie had had computerized X-ray sacs of his cerebral
tissue and X rays [angiograms] of his cerebral circulatory system, and they
indicated the presence of a tumor called meningioma just above the motor strip
on the left-hand side of his brain. While
such brain tumors are seldom malignant, the deadly thing about them is that
they have no room for expansion. Once
they attain a certain size they can cause paralysis, muteness, amnesia—or death
in a very short time.
They were sitting around a conference table: the Boss, two
resident surgeons and an intern on one side, Charlie, his sister and their
mother on the other. The angiograms were
mounted on a screen, and Charlie saw tangles of hack on white that shacked
around a central mass like the roots of an oak stretched out from its trunk.
Brokman read X rays the way most people read
newspapers. He drew a circle with his
fountain pen. “The tumor is just above
the motor strip,” he said. “That’s why
it gave you a leg seizure.” With a
flourish that was knotless comic for being compassionate, he touched his own
head with his fountain pen, describing a circle just behind the crown. “I’d say that the tumor is just about here.”
“Damn,” said Charlie, “that’s just where I felt it.” He was a short, stocky fellow with
hyperactive eyes. He was more composed
than his family. “What’s the danger?” he
asked. “What happens if you don’t
operate?”
Brockman was used to this question, and he got to the bottom
line so fast that no toom was left for anticipation or imagination. “Sooner or later it will kill you.”
The next question, although it was less serious, was a lot
more awkward: “What sort of incision do you make.”
Brockman indicated a U-shaped line in his head, a horseshoe
that began behind his left ear and ended in front of it and reached the midline
of the skull at its apex. “We make a cut
here, them another here; then we make a sort of trapdoor through the
skull. It’s a simple procedure.”
What Brockman was describing was a craniotomy. Of all stages in neurosurgery it is probably
the last dangerous, but it is also the most shocking, the supreme violation of
identity.
Mrs. White began to sob, and Brockman took her hand. “Come on, come on. It’s not as bad as that. Think about it for a while and let me know
what you decide.”
“Why should we think about it?” Charley said.
“It’s my decision ad I want it out.
I don’t want it growing in my head.
When can you do it?”
“How about next Thursday?”
The Boss and Charlie stood and shook hands.
Brockman’s work was a family tradition. Both his father and his grandfather had been
surgeons, professors of surgery, and chiefs of their departments. Operations were his theater, his prayer
meeting, and the consummation of the romance that energized his life. A short (five-foot-three) man of 65, he
claimed that when he entered the OR there was no time in the room, no
distraction, and no hunger. “There’s no
field so challenging as brain surgery,” he said, “none that lays down such
responsibility ad anxiety or imposes so many life-or-death decisions.”
Whenever Brockman discussed surgery, two themes appeared and
intertwined: primitivism and sexuality on the one hand, and “management power”
on the other. “Surgeons are
interventionists, activists by nature, people who seek solutions. We’re dealing with danger, blood, power,
conquering the man or woman on the table.
No wonder wives of patients fall in love with surgeons. Aren’t we the male who conquers her male?”
Charlie White’s night nurse had just left when Brockman
stopped by for evening rounds.
“You scared?”
“Yeah, a little.”
“You are afraid of dying.
Don’t be. We know what we’re
doing.”
“Okay,” Charlie laughed.
Brockman squeezed his hand and said, “As long as you keep
laughing, kid, you will do all right.”
Charlie tried to watch the ball game of TV, but it was no use. Terror rose in him; grotesque images of his
head split open, Brokman’s hands wrist-deep inside his skull. At 9 p.m., they gave him a Valium, and at
9:30 resident surgeon Benny Richmond came to shave his head.
The Valium helped; Charlie slept soundly until he was
awakened for pre-operative preparation for the following morning. There was much to do to get him on steroids
to decrees his intracranial pressure.
Orally, he got Dilantin and Phenobarbital for seizures, Nembutal for
terror. Then the operating-room
attendant wheeled Charlie’s bed into the hall.
It was 7:30 and the operating room was ready. Scrub nurses Millie Yeats and Esther Woolf
had arrived at seven to put the machines in place and lay out the
instruments—150 of them, rolled in blue towels on the stand that straddled the
operating table.
Charlie’s bed was pushed through the door and stopped
parallel to the operating table. Millie
asked Charlie if he could lift himself and slide across. “Why not?” he said, and then, as if they had
done him favor, “Thank you very much.”
The nurses and resident Jose Rivera removed his dressing
gown, covered him with a sheet and buckled leather straps across his chest and
thighs. His face white and his mouth
locked in a contorted smile, in turn Charlie looked terrified, helpless and
oblivious. The pace of the room had
quickened: Benny Richmond and nurse Lisa King arrived, and now there were five
people plugging him into machines, moving his legs, tilting the table, applying
leads for the EKG to his chest and a blood pressure strap to his arm.
There was no way to avoid the knowledge of what was about to
happen and no way, with the patient awake, to acknowledge it. The result was a sort of mindless chatter
among the staff, but it ceased abruptly with the arrival of Terry Schreiber,
the anesthesiologist. He brought a sense
of danger to the room, as though this were about to take a turn that no one
could control.
“How you doing, sport?” he asked.
“Okay, I guess.”
Schreiber broke open an I.V. kit and quickly found the vein
he wanted in Charlie’s wrist. “You’re
goanna have the sweetest sleep you ever knew.
Good night, sport.” Before half
the syringe was empty, Charlie’s head had keeled to the right.
With his loss of consciousness, the room abruptly increased
its velocity, like a satellite shifting orbit.
No appearance to maintain now, no need to screen the violence. Benny took a purple marking pen and
–centering himself by putting his little finger on Charlie’s nose and his thumb
on the peak of his skull—he drew a free-hand line along the midline of his
skull, then another from ear to ear, bisecting it.
Schreiber administered nitrous oxide through a mask and
finally halothane, the principal anesthetic agent. Carla Fredericks, Schreiber’s assistant,
inserted a long plastic tongue depressor with a light on the end obit, and
then, aiming an eight inch needle down Charlie’s throat, gave him a short of
lidocaine, to anesthetize his vocal cords and prevent them from going into Spam
from the general anesthetic. Withdrawing
the syringe, she clamped a bite-block over his tongue and turned on the central
IV line so that pancuronium, the paralytic agent administers along with
halothane, would immobilize every muscle except the heart, protecting Charlie
from bucking during surgery and moving his tumor around. Because Charlie was now incapable of
breathing for himself, she turned on the respirator.
Jose slid a greased catheter into Charlie’s urethra, taped
plastic covers over his eyes, inserted a needle and then a catheter in the
femoral artery in his right thigh (to track his blood pressure), and installed
a line in his hand through which, if required, he’d be given blood.
It was 7:50. Jose and
Benny checked the angiograms, and then positioned Charlie’s head on a black
rubber cushion with a hole in the center that looked like a huge chocolate
doughnut. Using the lines that Benny had
drawn as guides, they drew a flap on Charlie’s skull; five tiny circles and
then a pentagon connecting them.
That was as far as they could before scrubbing, so they
retired to the washroom for the elaborate cleansing ritual prescribed for all
who would touch the patient. When they
returned, dripping hands held high, Millie helped them into surgical gowns, masks
and skin-tight rubber gloves. Finally,
nothing showed but their eyes. Millie
clamped Benny’s headlight on his forehead and adjusted it, as he faced
Charlie’s head, so that it shone on the flap he’d drawn.
He took a syringe from the instrument stand and injected
Charlie’s scalp in a half-dozen places with saline solution to reduce its
vascularity before incision. Since each
injection caused a swelling like a large hive, the scalp looked like the belly
of a pregnant dog.
By now the steady beep of the oscilloscope could be heard,
its beautiful jagged lines—read outs of pulse and blood pressure—marching
across the screen above Charlie’s feet.
Every 30 seconds Carla would make what she called eye rounds, checking
vital signs through gauges on the anesthetic machine and listening—through
earphones that trailed under the bed sheet.
Since her work kept her close to his face, she was, of all those in the
room, most aware of Charlie as a person.
“Cute, isn’t he?” she said to Millie.
Benny made the first incision, a quick slice with the
scalpel along the forward line of the flap, at 8:40, and the scalp was peeled
away from the muscle beneath it about 15 minutes later. Three layers of tissue—scalp, muscle and the
membrane called the galea—had to be severed before bone was reached and
drilling begun. Charley’s scalp was
about a half-inch thick and the bone about a quarter-inch thick. Altogether, it would take 55 minutes to
complete the flap.
Bleeding was heavy along the incision, and after the blood
was suctioned and sponged, white plastic clips were installed to seal off the
vessels. When the lime of the flap had
been incised, the tissue beneath it was sliced with a very sharp knife. The flap was peeled back gently like the skin
of an orange and wrapped with a mesh-like material.
“Call the Boss,” Benny said.
“Tell him 30 minutes.”
When the Boss was exposed, six large holes, about the size
of those in a bowling ball, were drilled along the line of the flap with a
craniotomy, a stainless-steel cylinder that looked like a space gun and whined
like a baby pig when activated. The
craniotomy’s great feature was that, being air-powered, it responded negatively
to pressure. The harder the tissue it
encountered, the more power it generated.
Thus, the drill bit turned with maximum speed through bone and stopped
altogether when it met the soft tissue lay beneath it.
Benny had to get all his weight behind the craniotomy to
make it penetrate Charlie’s skull. He
leaned forward until his body was nearly 20 degrees of the vertical. Clearly, the brain was not meant to be
violated. When the holes were finished,
he then sawed out the line between the holes.
The saw moved almost imperceptibly, sending up trials of bone dust and
generating so much heat that it required constant irrigation. Now Benny threaded a flexible instrument
called a dural protector between the holes and slid it back and forth several
times to separate the bone from the brain beneath it. He rolled his head in a circle as if to
stretch his neck, then looked up at Millie on the stand. “Chisels, please.”
She handed him two stainless-steel instruments with blunt
one-inch blades, slapping them between his thumb and forefinger. After working them around the edges of the
flap, Benny elevated it gently until he was certain it was coming off the durra
and then lifted it clear. For the first
time, Charlie’s brain was visible, framed by the flap and covered by the silky
film of the durra like an embryo in its sac.
Brockman had arrived in the locker room just about when
Benny was calling for the chisels. As
always, he took a scrub sponge into the OR and continued to scrub, dripping
suds on the floor, while he inspected the flap that Benny had turned.
‘Looks good,” he said. “You’re getting better all the time.”
Brockman examined the angiograms while Millie pulled on his
gloves, and finally stepped up and probed the durra with his finger. Then he quickly opened it. Taut and resilient, it snapped out of the way
and the brain pushed through the opening like a tiny fist. It was 9:35
After marking a small incision, the Boss began cutting out a
piece of durra that more or less followed the flap. Finally, the durra flap was raised, wrapped
in moistened gauze and clamped out of the way.
In all its convolutions, oyster-gray and pink on its surface and almost black
at the folds the cortex was visible at last.
It was 9:45.
At the bottom of the exposure lay the tumor. Striated with blood vessels like the brain
around it but still sharply distinct from it, darker and smoother, it was
clearly alien. “Okay,” said the Boss,
when a good view had been exposed.
“There’s no reason from what I see that we shouldn’t get it all.”
The first target with meningiomas is their blood
supply. Since they’re highly vascular
tumors, they can hemorrhage if interred directly, but once their principal
sources have been legated, they can be manageable. In search of the feeding vessels, Brockman
worked his way around the tumor.
With that entire cutting, the doctors were using the suction
tubes a lot, and suddenly a piece of normal brain got caught and sucked—whoosh!
—Up the tube, gone forever into the central garbage receptacle. The normal tissue had come far from anything
crucial and would not be missed. To say
the least, Brockman took its departure in stride. “Damn,” he said. “There go the music lessons.”
Everyone cracked up.
But the pleasure was short-lived because Jose got his suction tube
entangled with the Boss’s. “Hey, Jose,
are you sleeping? Move it out of the
way!”
By ten o’clock Brockman had the tumor legated and separated
with Cottonoids from the brain around it.
His anger had settled, and the conversation at the table hade becomes
friendly, almost intimate.
The sounds of the OR became musical and hypnotic. The sizzle of the cautery, the flute-like
beep of the oscilloscope, the sighs of the respirator, the conversation, the
suction, the clink of instruments against each other like knives and forks at
the dinner table. It was all repetitive,
monotonous, as constant in its rhythm as a fugue.
By 10:15 they were extracting tumor. Using a scalpel first and then a copper
spoon, Brockman broke through the tumor’s capsule and dug it out in small,
bloody silvers, which he placed in the specimen glass on the instrument stand. Inside, the tumor’s texture looked a lot like
Cream of Wheat. By 10:40 half the tumor
was in the specimen glass, the rest had snaked up the suction tube and the Boss
was packing the empty cavity with Gel foam, a Styrofoam-like material that
promotes clotting. A few minutes later,
he said, “All right, let’s get out of here.”
By the time Brockman had showered, dressed and made his way
to the ninth floor, where, to use his words for it, he played a bit of God for
the White family, Charlie was almost reassembled.
At seven that evening Charlie was talking to his
mother. Tow days later, he was released
from the intensive-care unit and returned to the ward. He would need no radiation of chemotherapy
because the tumor, as Brokman had predicted, had turned out benign, but Charlie
would be on Dilating indefinitely, to protect him from seizures, and he would
have to consider himself, for the rest of his life, prone to meningioma.
His skin healed in a week, muscle and bone in 70 days. According to Brockman, all traces of surgery
were gone from his brain within a year.
Nothing was said or postulated about its traces in his mind, but then,
as they say, nothing was done to his mind anyway.
No comments:
Post a Comment